top of page
logo

Why Does a New Train Line Take 20 Years?

11 minutes ago
4 min read

In 1920, New York drew up plans for a subway under Second Avenue. The first short piece opened on 1 January 2017. That's almost a century, for three new stations.

That's an extreme case. But if you've ever waited for a "new line coming soon" in your own city, you know the feeling. Twenty years from idea to first ride is common. So where does all that time go?

I've spent much of my career on traffic and rail projects in the US and the Middle East. Here's my simple answer: most of the wait happens before anyone picks up a shovel.

Think of it as a kitchen remodel

Imagine you want a new kitchen. First you argue with your family about the layout. Then you ask the city for a permit. Then you save up, or wait for a loan. Then you hire a designer and pick a builder. Only then do the walls come down. And when they do, you find old pipes nobody knew were there.

A train line is the same story. The only difference is that the whole city is your family.

A recent opinion piece in Mass Transit magazine listed the usual causes of delay: money that arrives late, reviews that run long, surprise pipes and cables, and long testing. Let's take them one by one.

Step 1: Deciding (the slowest part)

Where should the line go? Which neighbourhoods get a station? Should it be a subway, a tram or a fast train? Everyone has an opinion, and they all vote.

Every election can reopen the question. A plan that one government loves, the next one may shrink, move or cancel. Years pass while the drawing sits in a drawer.

Step 2: Checking the impact

Before building, the project must study what it will do to the area. Engineers call this an environmental review. Think of it as knocking on every neighbour's door before you start a noisy remodel. You check noise, traffic, homes, wildlife, water and old buildings. Then you listen to people and fix the plan.

This step matters. It protects people and places. But on big projects it often takes longer than planned. And if the route changes, part of the work starts again.

Step 3: Finding the money

Rail lines cost billions. The money rarely arrives in one go. It comes in pieces from cities, regions and national governments, each with its own budget calendar. One missing piece can stop the whole puzzle.

Step 4: Digging, and the surprises underground

Under any old city lies a maze of water pipes, gas lines and cables. Some are on no map. Each one has to be found and moved before the tunnel goes in. That is slow, careful work.

Britain's new high-speed line, HS2, shows how long the whole chain can be. The government first looked at the idea in 2009. Parliament passed the law for the first section in 2017. Main building work began in 2020. In May 2026, the UK government said the first trains should run between 2036 and 2039. It also said that about two-thirds of the cost rise came from misjudging the work, underestimating it and inefficiency.

Step 5: Testing before the first passenger

When the tracks are done, the line is still not ready. Trains, signals, power and doors must all work together, again and again, with no one on board. Safety comes first, so this can take many months.

It doesn't have to take 20 years

Madrid is the famous counter-example. Between 1995 and 1999, the region opened about 56 km (35 miles) of new metro lines in four years. Then it kept going.

How? A case study by the Eno Center for Transportation points to a few habits. The main parties agreed that the metro was worth it. A small team of skilled engineers ran the projects. Contracts were split into smaller pieces. And the review rules for city transit were simpler. To be fair, the same study notes that part of it was paid for with borrowing that later hurt public finances.

My take

I think the hardest part of building a train line is not the building. It's deciding, and then sticking to the decision.

If I could change three things, I'd do this. Decide once, and protect that choice from every new election. Keep a small, expert team in charge from start to finish. And copy station and tunnel designs that already work, instead of starting fresh every time.

The other side has a point too. Careful reviews exist because past projects cut through neighbourhoods and nature without asking. Going faster should never mean skipping the people who live along the line.

The takeaway

When a new line takes 20 years, the delay is usually in the meetings, the permits and the money, not in the tunnel. Faster lines are possible when people agree early and stay agreed.

What about your city? Is there a train line you have been waiting for? Tell me in the comments.

For more technical knowledge, read Valerio's engineering articles at ibano.com/insights.

Sources and further reading

Photo: Brett Jordan / Unsplash

Comments


bottom of page